Why This Playbook Matters
It is 1 a.m. on a Saturday. A mother’s son was arrested for DWI two hours ago. She searches for a defense lawyer and fills in the form on three or four sites.
The firm that answers first usually gets the first talk. Most people hire the first lawyer who gets back to them.
Most criminal defense firms lose cases in three places:
- They talk to every kind of charge at the same time.
- They answer enquiries the next business day, when most arrests happen on nights and weekends.
- They stop talking to old enquiries, past clients and referral sources.
This playbook fixes those three places. Do the steps in order. Each step makes the next step work.
Cook does the work in each step. If a thing spends money or goes to a potential client, it waits for YOU to approve it. See How to approve work.
What you will set up
- One kind of charge to go after first, and one offer for those people.
- A page that asks your intake questions and collects the person's number.
- Facebook and Instagram ads with the wording your state bar requires.
- A reply to every new enquiry within minutes, day or night, and a consultation booked on your calendar.
- Steady cases from reviews, old enquiries and referral sources, without ad spend.
Step 1: Choose the Cases You Want First
Why This Matters
A first-time DWI, a drug possession charge and an assault or family violence charge bring different people and different fears.
The DWI client asks: will I lose my licence and my job? The drug client asks: will this stay on my record? The family member asks: how do we get him out, and what happens next?
A page that talks to all of them does not answer any of them well. And broad ads bring calls about charges you do not take, in courts where you do not practice.
Pick ONE charge. Then every later step is easier. The page, the ads and the follow-up all use the same words.
What to Do First
- Ask Cook’s Research department to compare two or three kinds of charge in your area. Ask what those people worry about, what they search for, and what other firms offer them.
- Pick one charge. Write your offer for those people in one sentence.
- Keep the other charges for later. You can do this playbook again for each one.
I’m a criminal defense attorney in San Antonio. Compare three groups in my area: people with a first DWI arrest, people charged with drug possession, and people charged with assault or family violence. Tell me what they and their families worry about, what other firms offer them, and which group I should go after first.
Cook writes the comparison. It also writes a one-page offer that you can change. These are the first tasks in a new workspace. See Why is everything locked? and the Research department.
What Cook Found for Reyes Defense Law
- Start with first DWI cases: Cook recommends a test of first DWI before the other groups. Texas DPS guidance gives a short ALR action window, so the first message is urgent and clear.
- Families worry about practical limits: For DWI, the main worries are driving and work access. For family-violence cases, families worry about orders, contact, housing, and children.
- Lead with a deadline review: Cook suggests a first-time DWI intake route around the notice, the deadline, driving and work needs, and charge paperwork. An attorney must review all statements about the ALR process.
This is Cook’s real answer for a made-up Reyes Defense Law. Your answer depends on your area.
Step 2: Build a Page That Collects Case Enquiries
Why This Matters
Your ads, your posts and your referral sources all need one place to send people.
People charged with a crime feel fear and shame. Often the person who fills in the form is a parent or a partner, not the person charged. A calm page with a clear next step earns the form.
A good page does the first minutes of your intake call for you. It asks:
- what the charge is and which county,
- when the next court date is,
- who is filling in the form and how to reach them.
When the enquiry comes in, you already know which cases to call first.
What to Do First
- Ask Cook for a page with a short quiz. Put one question on each screen. Then a scared person can answer fast on a phone.
- Ask your intake questions: is this for you or a family member, the charge, the county, the next court date if they know it, and their phone number.
- Do not ask what happened on the page. Keep the facts of the case for the consultation with the attorney.
- Tell Cook what to do with a case you do not take, for example a federal charge or a county where you do not practice. The quiz can send them to a different screen, not to your calendar.
- Give Cook the exact wording your state bar requires, for example an “Attorney Advertising” label and the name of the responsible attorney. Cook puts it on the page.
- Do not promise a result. Ask Cook to avoid words like “dismissed”, “beat your case” or “guaranteed”.
- Read the page, then approve it. Cook puts it on the internet at a real web address. Cook can make the photo and the logo.
Build me a page for people arrested for a first DWI in Bexar County, and their families. Ask a few quick questions, one at a time: is this for you or a family member, was it a first DWI, the date of the arrest, the next court date if they know it, and their phone number. If the arrest was outside Bexar, Comal or Guadalupe County, thank them and end the quiz. Put this text at the bottom of the page, word for word: “Attorney Advertising. Responsible attorney: Marisol Reyes, San Antonio, Texas.”
More about pages and forms: Building a lead generating asset.
What the Person Sees
Step 1 of 5
The Page Cook Built
Cook built this page from the request above, for a made-up business, Reyes Defense Law. Cook also made the photo and the logo.

Step 3: Run Facebook and Instagram Ads in the Right Category
Why This Matters
Most people search Google right after an arrest. Facebook and Instagram reach the people in the weeks after, while they wait for court and look for a lawyer. Leads there often cost less.
Meta has no special ad category for legal services. A defense ad that does not offer a loan or a job runs without one.
Your state bar has its own rules for lawyer ads. Some states require a label such as “Attorney Advertising”. Many states forbid promises about results. An ad that breaks those rules can put your licence in trouble, even if Meta runs it. So put the bar’s wording in the ads BEFORE the campaign starts, not after.
What to Do First
- Connect your Meta ad account to Cook. See Cook + Meta Ads.
- Ask Cook to write the ads and set up the campaign. Cook makes the campaign paused. Then it shows you an approval card with the budget, the ads and the special ad category.
- Give Cook the same bar wording you gave for the page. Cook puts it in the ads.
- Keep the ads calm. No handcuffs, no mugshots, no “beat your DWI”. Show the attorney and the next step.
- Check the special ad category on the approval card before you approve.
- Want people to stay inside Facebook? Ask for a Meta lead form, not a link to your page. Each form a person sends becomes a lead in Cook. Your follow-up from Step 4 then starts by itself.
- Start with a small daily budget. Cook reads the results. It tells you which ads to stop and where to move the budget. You approve each change.
Write three Facebook ads for my first DWI page, for people in Bexar, Comal and Guadalupe counties. Speak to the person charged in two of them and to a worried parent in one. Put “Attorney Advertising. Responsible attorney: Marisol Reyes.” in every ad. No promises about results. Set up a campaign at $50 a day.
Your state bar decides the wording, not Cook. Cook does not know your state's advertising rules. Give Cook the exact text your bar requires, and read every page and ad before you approve it. If your state asks you to file ads with the bar, do that before the campaign starts.
Google search ads. If you already run Google search ads, connect Google Ads so Cook can read your campaigns, keywords and spend. Cook does not make new Google search campaigns.
What Your Approval Card Shows
- Campaign
- San Antonio First DWI | Defense
- Daily budget
- $50
- Special ad category
- None
- Starts
- Paused
Cook makes each campaign paused. Approving the card creates it, still paused. It starts only when you approve switching it on.
What Real Ads in This Industry Say
We read the Facebook and Instagram ads that 37 businesses like yours are running now, in Meta’s public Ad Library (October 12, 2026). Ads that run for months usually work, so start from what they repeat.
- Offer a free consultation. This is the most common offer in the set. “Get a Free Legal Consultation 24/7” (see the ad)
- Name the place in the first line. The first line asks a question and names the city or county. “ARRESTED IN ROCKFORD, IL?” (see the ad)
- Say what is at stake. The ad names the job, the future and the freedom that the person can lose. “When your job, your future, your freedom and your life is on the line” (see the ad)
The longest-running ad has run for more than 5 years. It is one plain line that names the firm and the city, with a Get directions button (see the ad).
Give these to Cook when you ask for ads, as research, not to copy.
The Ads Cook Made for Reyes Defense Law
Cook made these ads from the page after reading the real ads above. Each ad uses the page’s photo, colours and headline.


Step 4: Answer Every Enquiry Within Minutes
Why This Matters
This step turns ad money into retained cases.
About half of defense searches happen outside business hours, and most DWI arrests happen Friday to Sunday. That is when your phone goes to voicemail.
A person who gets a calm text at 1 a.m., while they still hold their phone, answers it. A person who hears back on Monday has often hired the firm that answered first.
What to Do First
- Get a texting number. After you approve it, Cook files the carrier registration for you. See What phone numbers and texting cost.
- Set up a booking page for your first call, for example a 20-minute free consultation. Add early morning and weekend hours if you can. Cook sends the person reminders before the call. To add a Zoom link to every booking, see Putting a Zoom link on every booking.
- Switch on the AI sales rep for new enquiries. It texts and emails each new person in your words, day or night. It asks your intake questions, books the consultation on your calendar, and follows up with people who go quiet. See the Sales department.
- Tell the sales rep it does NOT give legal advice. It books the consultation. Questions like “should he talk to the police?” or “will this be dismissed?” are for the attorney on the call. Tell it to ask for no details of what happened.
- If you want, let the sales rep answer calls to your number. Then a 2 a.m. call gets an answer and a booked consultation, not voicemail.
- Test the follow-up routine before you switch it on. Ask for it as below, then press Test: Cook runs the full follow-up with a made-up person, and a made-up worried parent. Then you can read EVERY message first.
When someone fills in my first DWI page, text them within two minutes, any time of day. Be calm and short. Ask if the person charged is out of jail yet and if they have a court date. Then book a 20-minute free consultation with me, as early as my calendar allows. Never give legal advice and never ask what happened; say the attorney will go over that on the call. If they don’t reply, text again in the morning.
Nothing texts a potential client until you switch it on. A follow-up you have just made is off. It waits until you turn it on yourself, and turning it off stops it at once. See Answering people without doing it yourself.
What the Family Member Gets
Step 5: Work Your Reviews, Old Enquiries and Referral Sources
Why This Matters
Criminal defense clients rarely come back, and many do not tell friends who they hired. So word of mouth is weak.
Three things still bring cases without ad money:
- Reviews. A scared person reads them before they call. A client who is happy with the result will often leave one when you ask.
- Old enquiries. Many people wait weeks before they hire. A court date gets closer and they are ready.
- Referral sources. Attorneys who do not take criminal cases, and past clients’ families, send people they trust to you.
What to Do First
- Import your old enquiries, past clients and referral attorneys from a spreadsheet (CSV), or bring them in from GoHighLevel. See Cook + GoHighLevel.
- Give old enquiries a reason to talk again, for example “your court date is close, it is not too late to get a lawyer.” Cook writes the email or text. It shows it to you before it goes out.
- Ask for reviews. Ask Cook to text your closed clients the link to your Google review page. Choose who gets it.
- Send one useful email each month to referral attorneys, for example the kinds of cases you take. To send from your own address, see Send email from your own domain.
- Post on a schedule. Connect Facebook, Instagram, LinkedIn and your Google Business Profile. Cook writes and schedules plain-language posts, such as what happens after a DWI arrest in Texas, with your bar wording. You approve the schedule. See the Marketing department.
Here’s a spreadsheet of people who asked about a DWI in the last 90 days and did not hire anyone yet. Text each one: Reyes Defense Law still has free consultations this week, and it is not too late before a court date. No legal advice. Put my Attorney Advertising line in it. Show me the text before it goes out.
Check the Numbers Every Week
Each step above changes one number. Look at all of them once a week.
Then change one thing at a time.
Every Monday at 8am, send me last week’s numbers: new enquiries, how many came in after 6pm or on the weekend, consultations booked, ad spend and cost per booked consultation.
What a Month Can Look Like
These numbers are simulated. They are for a made-up firm, Reyes Defense Law, on a $50 a day budget. They show what your Monday report has in it. Your numbers depend on your area, your offer and your budget.
Final Thoughts
- Pick one charge. Write one offer for those people and their families.
- Build one page that asks your intake questions and carries your bar wording.
- Run ads with the wording your state bar requires. Start small.
- Answer EVERY enquiry within minutes, nights and weekends too. Book the consultation and leave legal advice to the attorney.
- Ask for reviews and follow up with old enquiries. Then cases come in without ad money.
Do the steps in this order. Each step gives the next step something to use:
- the page needs an offer,
- the ads need a page,
- the follow-up needs enquiries.
Run an agency with criminal defense clients? Do these steps in each client’s workspace. See The Marketing Agency Playbook.